8 Unique and Quirky Furniture Stores in Lancaster, Ohio

This distinctive furniture will help you make your house feel like home

a bed and pillow display at a furniture store
Google reviews
1746 N Memorial Dr Lancaster, Ohio 43130
(740) 687-1516
Homes for sale in 


Sarah Stager


Jan 21, 2021

What’s a Rich Text element?



The rich text element allows you to create and format headings, paragraphs, blockquotes, images, and video all in one place instead of having to add and format them individually. Just double-click and easily create content.

Static and dynamic content editing

A rich text element can be used with static or dynamic content. For static content, just drop it into any page and begin editing. For dynamic content, add a rich text field to any collection and then connect a rich text element to that field in the settings panel. Voila!

How to customize formatting for each rich text

Headings, paragraphs, blockquotes, figures, images, and figure captions can all be styled after a class is added to the rich text element using the "When inside of" nested selector system.

Moving to a new place is always intimidating — new people, new places, possibly a new job — and in the midst of all that new-ness, your home should be your haven. At first, your house will just be a bunch of empty, echoey rooms, but once you start filling those rooms with furniture that you love, that house will truly become a home. To get you started on the construction of your own personal refuge, here’s a list of the best furniture stores in Lancaster, Ohio.

Don’s Furniture and Mattress Showroom

The Best Brands at Massive Discounts

Book shelf
This stepped shelving unit is just one example of sleek furniture carried by Don’s. Image courtesy of Don’s Furniture and Mattress Showroom on Yelp.

1118 E Main St

Lancaster, OH 43130

View homes for sale in 43130>


Mon-Fri: 10am-8pm

Sat: 10am-5pm



Don’s Furniture is a family-owned business well known for their friendly customer service, reasonable prices, and quality furniture. Their constant sales make it easy to get name brand furniture such as Serta, Jackson Furniture, Tempur Pedic, and others, at a greatly discounted price. Special financing offers, including No Credit Check, are available. You won’t have to worry about delivery, either, as Don’s personally delivers every piece they sell.

“If you are looking for furniture store in Lancaster this is the place.  Excellent customer service!  They do not jump on you when you walk in the door and then hover over you.  They let you browse.  Store is much bigger than it appears on the outside.  It just seemed to keep going.  Very nice selection of furniture and the prices are extremely reasonable.” - Kathleen B. on Yelp

Colony Classics & Interiors

Cute Antiques and Unique Items

2 sofa
If this picture doesn’t look homey, I don’t know what does. Image courtesy of Colony Classics & Interiors on Yelp.

602 N High St

Lancaster, OH 43130

View homes for sale in 43130>


Tue-Sat: 10am-4pm


The unique furniture in Colony Classics & Interiors is inspired by traditional colonial designs, with much of their furniture handcrafted by Amish. Best of all, their furniture is unmistakably cozy. They even have a cat room in which they display tapestries that feature our furry friends. If you really want the complete country traditional look, you could seek advice from the store’s on-site design consultant, and maybe even order custom-made furniture.

“Purchased a chair and other items a couple years ago. Very satisfied. I do not live close to Lancaster, Oh. Had items sent. Looks as if plenty of more unique items for awesome decor in our homes.” - Margie Jennings Ellis on Facebook

Miller’s Furniture

Amish-made, durable, and detailed

long table
If ever you need an extremely long table, Miller’s is the place to go. Image courtesy of Miller’s Furniture on Yelp.

3040 Cols-Lancaster Rd

Lancaster, OH 43130

View homes for sale in 43130>


Mon-Thu: 10am-6pm

Fri: 10am-8pm

Sat: 10am-5pm


One of the many furniture stores featuring Amish and Menonnite craftsmanship in Lancaster, Miller’s Furniture stands out with their low prices, wide variety, and excellent craftsmanship. Their specialty is woodwork, and each of their pieces is durable enough to last a lifetime, and perhaps even become a family heirloom. Choose carefully, because this furniture is made to last!

“Beautiful, high quality, well-made pieces at reasonable prices. And a large showroom with a wide range of other furniture! I will be back! Highly recommend! Friendly, helpful associates too!” - Anna A. on Yelp

Amanda Furniture Store

A local hidden gem

Furniture store
At first glance, this place resembles a farm stand, but in fact it contains new, used, and antique furniture pieces. Image courtesy of Roadtrippers.

302 E Main St

Amanda, OH 43102

View homes for sale in 43102>


Mon: 10am-5pm

Wed-Thu: 10am-5pm

Fri: 10am-6pm

Sun: 12pm-5pm


Amanda Furniture Store is set up like a market, with several booths manned by local craftspeople that specialize in different kinds of furniture. Because of this, you’ll be able to find the best of whatever you happen to be looking for. There’s also a section of the store with their own furniture, as well as an area for auctions which is put to good use every Friday night. Step into the store, and you’ll be greeted by so many treasures, it’ll be hard to pick just one.

“Super friendly staff as soon as we walked in the door! This place does auctions on Friday nights & has craft & antique vendor spaces up front. We stopped in because of a CraigsList ad we saw for a furniture piece. It did not pan out as expected, but did find a few other treasures to salvage & upcycle.” - Hannah M. on Yelp

Big Sandy Superstore

Unbeatable Prices and a Wide Selection

Furniture displayed in a store.
This carefully-arranged display room has just a few pieces of the great collection at Big Sandy. Image courtesy of Gwen W. on Yelp

1858 North Memorial Dr

Lancaster, OH 43130

View homes for sale in 43130>


Mon-Sat: 10am-9pm

Sun: 1pm-6pm




If you’re looking to create a home on a budget, Big Sandy Superstore is just the place to go. Their prices are as low as it gets, and if another store has prices that are lower, they will match it on the spot. Unlike Miller’s, however, their furniture is not built to endure generations of use — so in general it might be best to purchase more transient pieces of furniture here. They allow any crediting options you could possibly think of, including no credit, layaway, and other special financing.

“We ended up going from "just looking" to purchasing a stove, microwave and a dishwasher. I can honestly say we weren't ready to buy but Doug made it such a great experience and gave us such a great deal that we decided it would be crazy not to buy right then and there.” - Gary F. on Yelp

Sticks and Stones Studio

Unique Used and Vintage Items

 antique shop
As their signs proclaim, this secondhand antique shop is all about rehoming items that have been and will be well-loved. Image courtesy of Matt P. on Yelp.

4 E Waterloo St

Canal Winchester, OH 43110

View homes for sale in 43110>


Wed-Fri: 12pm-5pm

Sat: 10am-5pm


This shop is the very definition of cute, crammed with unique furniture and knick-knacks, and decorated by old rolling ladders, wood floors, and tin ceilings. In addition to their stock of farmhouse-inspired furniture, Sticks and Stones Studio also carries Annie Sloan Chalk Paint, specially designed for painting furniture without priming or sanding. You could use this paint to truly make a piece of furniture your own, and don’t worry if you don’t have much experience with remodeling furniture — the store also offers workshops that will teach you how to use the paint.

“There are two very large rooms to this store and the items ranged from older original furniture, repainted or re-purposed furniture, nick knacks, jewelry, wall hangings, handmade cards, and all manner of lovely items to decorate your home. The owner was there during my visit and was very friendly and helpful. There were a few other stores of this nature in the immediate area (it's a great corner of Canal Winchester to spend a few hours) but this store was the biggest.” - Melissa M. on Yelp

Georgie Emerson Vintage

Creamy White Farmhouse Vibes

 Georgie Emerson Vintage
This carefully curated shop is perfect for those going for the farmhouse look. Image courtesy of Georgie Emerson Vintage.

360 W Waterloo St

Canal Winchester, Ohio 43110

View homes for sale in 43110>


Wed-Fri: 12pm-5pm

Sat: 10am-5pm


Located right next door to Sticks and Stones Studio, this little shop is run by the owner, Polly. and stocked by her friends, who provide her with hand-painted signs, jewelry, artwork, and so on — all handmade. In addition to these unique decorative items, she also carries a wide array of vintages that have stood the test of time. These one-of-a-kind pieces are sure to make your space feel like your own.

“When I need a unique gift for a friend for a birthday or special occasion, I go to Georgie's. It is also quickly becoming the place to go to get decorating ideas for our 200 y/o Home. I love, love their new bigger space and am already planning another trip soon to get more items for my home decorating projects. I just have to pace myself a little.” - Julie M. on Yelp


Huge Selection of True Vintages and Antiques

Antiques jewelry
Every corner of this place contains a new delight. Image courtesy of Matt P. on Yelp.

1 S High St

Canal Winchester, OH 43110

View homes for sale in 43110>


Wed-Fri: 10:30am-6:30pm


To finish off the trifecta, this cozy vintage shop is across the street from both Sticks and Stones Studio and Georgie Emerson Vintage. CornerSmith is well-known as one of the best vintage furniture shops in the area, and their great customer service and variety of distinctive and well-crafted pieces makes it easy to see why. Like the other shops, they mix and match new items with true vintages, which means that even if vintage isn’t your thing, you can still find something that suits your tastes.

“I just LOVE this place.  If I need a neat gift, not the usual, this is my go to.  The local flair, with quality pieces, make this a great shop to go to often as the inventory and look is always changing. I defy anyone to find more friendly workers!” - Julia L. on Yelp

Hopefully this list will help you find some items to start filling up those cold, empty rooms and make moving a little less daunting. You may have to face a lot of “new,” but your new furniture should help you feel more comfortable, not less. Each of these stores holds different treasures, so keep exploring until you feel that your house is sufficiently homey.

Discover your dream home in German Village, OH.

Learn More
February 3, 2020
For questions on this blog, click here.


All Related content

Be The First to Know. Join Our Newsletter.

Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form