6 Fantastic Bakeries in Bexley, OH

Whether You’re Looking for Some Classic Baked Goods or a New Sweet Treat, Bakeries in Bexley Have You Covered.

Greater Columbus Area
Google reviews
681 High St, Worthington, OH 43085
(614) 888-7400
Homes for sale in 
Greater Columbus Area


Meghan Zonno


Jan 21, 2021

What’s a Rich Text element?



The rich text element allows you to create and format headings, paragraphs, blockquotes, images, and video all in one place instead of having to add and format them individually. Just double-click and easily create content.

Static and dynamic content editing

A rich text element can be used with static or dynamic content. For static content, just drop it into any page and begin editing. For dynamic content, add a rich text field to any collection and then connect a rich text element to that field in the settings panel. Voila!

How to customize formatting for each rich text

Headings, paragraphs, blockquotes, figures, images, and figure captions can all be styled after a class is added to the rich text element using the "When inside of" nested selector system.

We all have a sweet tooth. Whether your kryptonite is cookies or cakes, scones or pastries, these Bexley bakeries will always leave you wishing for more. 

Bexley, OH is a suburb just East of Columbus. While on the hunt for your favorite baked goods, you can stroll down their very walkable Main Street

Here is a sneak peak of the bakeries you can find in the Bexley area:

  • Hart & Batter
  • Cherbourg Bakery
  • Kittie’s Cafe
  • Block Bagels Bexley
  • Matt’s Bakery
  • Resch’s Bakery

These bakeries are very unique, offering something for everyone! There are keto, vegan, and kosher options, in addition to your classic baked goods. Now, let’s dive into the delicious bakery options that Bexley has to offer.

Three vanilla cupcakes with white frosting and sprinkles sit on a wooden surface.
Keto cupcakes and cakes galore are what this first bakery has to offer!

Hart & Batter

Bexley | hartandbatter.com

Hart & Batter is one of Bexley’s newest bakeries, opening in 2020. The bakery at the moment is a licensed home bakery. You can order your items on their website for contactless deliveries. There currently is a two day notice required for all orders. 

The delivery isn’t the only special thing Hart & Batter has to offer. It is also the first keto, low-carb & sugar free mobile bakery. To fulfill this mission, Hart & Batter uses a combination of almond, tapioca, and coconut flour. The sweeteners are all natural like monk fruit and allulose.

Keto cupcakes are available in quantities of 2, 4, 6, and 12. 

While this type of bakery is non-traditional, the reviews for it are all amazing, like this one from Kristi J. on Yelp:

“My husband and I have ordered cupcakes from Crystal twice now and I have to say that the cupcakes were phenomenal.  I was hesitant initially because the cupcakes are on the pricey side, but they are worth every penny!  If I could, I'd order some every week.  Before starting Keto, we used Polka dot cupcakes which are awesome, but not Keto friendly. Thank u so much Crystal for giving us the same quality and deliciousness!” -Yelp Review

Free contactless deliveries are available to any Bexley address. There is a $5 charge for any delivery in the 207 loop. There is also the option for pickup every night from 6-7 at Bexley Market District parking lot. 

Various pastries are arranged on serving trays in a display case.
Cherbourg Bakery has you covered with their gluten free, nut free, and dye free baked goods.

Cherbourg Bakery

541 S. Drexel Ave. | Bexley | cherbourgbakery.com

Cherbourg Bakery, named after owner Geri’s favorite place, the port town of Cherbourg, France, is another great stop in your tour of Bexley’s bakeries. 

At Cherbourg, they pride themselves on being a gluten, nut, and dye free bakery making this the perfect spot for those with nut and gluten allergies. These products have never been in the kitchen so there is no need to worry even a little!

Another thing that separates Cherbourg from the crowd is that they bake in very small batches due to their following of traditional recipes. 

Recipes are shared on their blog on their website. Are you looking for a Citrus Pound Cake with Strawberry Butter? Or maybe a Flourless Chocolate Cake? Maybe some Pumpkin Roll? Cherbourg’s blog has all of this and more!

While their menu does have staples like zucchini mini loaf, muffins, and scones the bakers love to experiment. That means that the more you stop by the more likely you are to find a new sweet treat that isn’t always available on the menu.

“My first time in this cute little shop. I tried the sun-dried tomato strata.  Very flavorful, even my baby loved it and kept asking for more. Make sure to have them warm it up for you. I also got the glazed pumpkin donut which was so moist and not too sweet, I should've gotten more of those! The first bite of the cinnamon roll was great but then it crumbled on me and became messy. My husband didn't mind and loved the roll. Definitely will come back to try their other pastries.” -Yelp Review

If you’re looking to grab a snack here, you can stop in the store or order ahead on their website. They also do catering. 

You can keep up to date with them on their Instagram as well.

A pie and some other baked goods, along with tea, are set out on a wooden counter.
More baked goods are coming your way thanks to the women-owned Kittie’s Cafe.

Kittie’s Cafe

2424 E. Main Street | Bexley | | kittiescakes.com

Kittie’s Cafe not only serves baked goods, but meals as well. You can start off your day with a biscuit, scone, cinnamon roll, or breakfast sandwich before the menu changes at noon. Once lunch rolls around, Kittie’s serves sandwiches on homemade focaccia bread. Kittie’s serves delicious homemade pastries as well as fresh coffee from Stumptown Coffee Roasters as well.

Their menu of baked goods includes cinnamon rolls that have been voted best in Columbus, an impressive feat for a large city. There are also biscuits and jams, scones, cakes, cupcakes, and cookies to look out for when ordering. Along with the regular menu, there are always seasonal changes to look out for!

You can create your own breakfast sandwich or opt for a one like the Cheddar Jalapeño Biscuit with egg & pimento cheese. Lunch specials range from Caprese Baguette to Chicken Salad. As for drinks, there are a wide variety of coffees and teas like the popular Lavender Latter. 

If you’re a fan of Kittie’s, then make sure to check out their catering services here. They can do business events, weddings, and parties like showers and birthdays.

Kittie’s has a lovely outdoor seating area and is also a dog friendly establishment. 

“Kittie's is an adorable treat shop in German Village with amazing cinnamon rolls and chocolate chip scones. They don't have a huge variety of anything but I appreciate that they do a few things really well. The Bexley location has more options. They also have a decent coffee selection to go with their treats so that is nice. Parking in German Village is always a mess but Kitties is worth roaming around for a spot.” -Yelp Review

Next time you’re craving something sweet, check out Kittie’s and their award winning cinnamon rolls!

Two bagels, cut in half are displayed on a counter with some cut up radishes and green onions.
New York style bagels are hard to come by the farther you get from the city. Thankfully, Block’s provides Bexley with this treat!

Block’s Bagels Bexley

3012 E Broad St | bexleyblocks.com

Are you looking for the best bagel but can’t make it to NYC? Look no further than Block’s Bagels.

Started by husband and wife Hal and Audry Block, the two began their business after moving from New York City and not being able to find a suitable bagel. Now, some 50 years later, their business and bagels are still a staple of their community.

Block’s serves breakfast all day long. The menu is large, so there is surely going to be something for everyone. Whether you want a breakfast sandwich, challah french toast, or something else, you can find it here!

Aside from breakfast, they also have a deli that offers soups, sandwiches, salads, and desserts. Desserts include homemade cookies, brownies, and rugelach.

As for bagels, Block’s offers over 26 different kinds of New York style bagels. This style is boiled then baked.

“We LOVE Block's! From the hot breakfast sandwiches to the fresh-made deli sandwiches to the variety of bagels and sweet treats - you are sure to never be disappointed! Also, be prepared to wait! There is always a line of customers whenever we arrive. That's how good they are! Everyone is constantly coming back for more! - Yelp Review 

Block’s does delivery, takeout, and dine in. There are also covered outdoor seating options.

Several different breads are situated n display in baskets.
Fresh bread, pastries, cakes, and cookies galore are waiting for you at Matt’s Bakery.

Matt’s Bakery

3675 E Broad St. | mattsbakery.com

Matt’s Bakery, owned by married couple Matt and Mindy is a full service kosher bakery. 

All the baked goods are milk and dairy free though eggs are used in the baking process. There are also no nuts in any of the items except the pecan pie, which is made separately. So for all those who struggle with allergies or live a kosher lifestyle, this might be the spot for you!

They have an extensive menu including bread, cakes, cookies, pies, and pastries. 

For breads, there are many options from pita pockets to challah to bagels and many others. Pastries sold here include babka, cannolis, cream puffs, and Eclairs among others. Their pies are of the fruit variety including blueberry, strawberry, and apple. These are just a few of their many items, so be sure to check out their full menu!

“There are very few kosher bakeries available so having Matt's within driving distance is a plus regardless. But it is also very, very good! We've ordered birthday cakes on two occasions and both times they were excellent....light, moist and delicious. The frosting: wonderful!    Recently we tried their Knishes. Need to go to NYC to get anything good. We're fans....and will  be returning for more” -Yelp Review

For catering information and pricing call (614) 237-4848.

A pie, a loaf of bread, and a powdered loaf are displayed on a wooden counter with white flowers and pine cones.
Though this bakery might be the farthest away (only by a few minutes), that should not stop you from making a visit to this family owned business!

Resch’s Bakery

4061 E Livingston Ave. | Reschbakery.com

Resch’s Bakery is a family owned bakery that has been operating for over 100 years. Their motto is “life is too short to eat bad desserts” and they truly live up to it with a large menu full of freshly made tasty treats.

The bakery has holiday specials on certain days like St. Patrick’s Day, Mother’s and Father’s day, Halloween, and others.

Their menu is full of great items. Their pastries include danishes, turnovers, and cream horns. If you’re looking for pies, make sure to check out their pumpkin, sweet potato, pecan, or cherry. If you’re not in the market for a sweet dessert, they have freshly made pretzels and bagels as well.

Resch’s is there for all your celebratory needs as well. They have cakes for every occasion from birthdays to weddings, graduations to holidays. They also make cakes for weddings and baby showers.

Brandon J. left a great yelp review that speaks to the Bakery’s ability to accommodate their customer’s needs: 

“So my son decided to wait until 6 days before his birthday to request a specific cake! Usually I have his cake ordered 30 days before, esp since his birthday is close to a HUGE BAKERY HOLIDAY!... The cupcakes turned out AMAZING, the staff was very friendly and took great care of us. -Yelp Review 

To keep up with Resch’s Bakery, check out their Facebook and Instagram.

A layered cake is on display amongst other baked goods.
Brexey has so many places to visit for baked goods that you could make a bucket list out of them.

Brexley, Ohio is a great place to live, and that is definitely in part due to the immense amount of bakeries in the area. Whatever you are looking for, whether that be New York style bagels, specialty cakes, keto, or some pastries, Brexley has it for you in one of their many bakeries. 

Discover your dream home in German Village, OH.

Learn More
June 11, 2021
For questions on this blog, click here.


All Related content

Be The First to Know. Join Our Newsletter.

Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form