Fill Up on Carbs With the Top 8 Best Pizza Shops in Sunbury, Ohio

Are you visiting or moving to Sunbury, Ohio? Make sure you know what pizza shops to check out with the top eight best ones around!

slice of pizza


Sara Nuss


Jan 21, 2021

What’s a Rich Text element?



The rich text element allows you to create and format headings, paragraphs, blockquotes, images, and video all in one place instead of having to add and format them individually. Just double-click and easily create content.

Static and dynamic content editing

A rich text element can be used with static or dynamic content. For static content, just drop it into any page and begin editing. For dynamic content, add a rich text field to any collection and then connect a rich text element to that field in the settings panel. Voila!

How to customize formatting for each rich text

Headings, paragraphs, blockquotes, figures, images, and figure captions can all be styled after a class is added to the rich text element using the "When inside of" nested selector system.

There is nothing better than a delicious slice of pizza. From toppings like veggies, pepperoni, bacon, mushrooms, and to the selective person, pineapple, there are many different ways to customize pizza to make it the way that you like it. Pizza is something that many people like and it can even come in Chicago style, deep dish, Sicillian, and so much more. Well, we think that’s enough talk about what kinds of pizza you can get. Let’s talk about why this article is unique!

Sometimes with moving to a new city, or even just visiting, it can be a challenge to find the best places to go out and order food from. If you’re in or around Sunbury, Ohio, we know that this can be a struggle when you already don’t know what’s around, so we’re here to help you. We’ve compiled a list of the top eight best pizza joints in Sunbury that you need to check out ASAP. Let’s begin the journey of enjoying the extra carbs, all for a great reason, which is to familiarize yourself with the area! Experience Sunbury, Ohio for what it is at these great pizza shops today!

Good Fella’z Pizzeria

Enjoy the best slice of Sicilian pizza you’ll ever have, along with some delicious specialty pizzas!

good fella'z pizzeria
Try out a delicious slice of Sicilian pizza along with many other tasty things when you go to Good Fella’z Pizzeria today! Image courtesy of Yelp. 

245 N Columbus Street | Sunbury |

If you want to enjoy a delicious slice of Sicilian pizza from a local pizza joint in Sunbury, Ohio, then you need to stop by Good Fella’z Pizzeria today! Their pizzas range from small to large, and you can try out their Sicilian pizza, along with their other specialty pizzas, such as their french bread pizza, the hot and spicy, buffalo chicken, the Hawaiian, and so much more. Good Fella’z is a fun, old school pizza joint that everyone of all ages can enjoy, so make sure to stop over today!

“Well - thank GOODNESS we found you as soon as we did. We had lost all faith in good pizza so we decided that dieting was better and we would never eat pizza again.  Until we found Good Fella'z Pizzeria.” - Yelp Review 

Long Branch Pizza

This pizza joint has been named one of the best in Sunbury, so make sure to stop by today!

long branch pizza
Check out Long Branch Pizza today for some delicious pizza that the town of Sunbury raves about! Image courtesy of Long Branch Pizza. 

34 S Vernon Street | Sunbury |

If you want to go to a place where their pizza has been proclaimed to be some of the best in the town of Sunbury, Ohio, then you need to go to Long Branch Pizza today for some of the tastiest pizza you’ll ever have in your life! This restaurant is owned by two women that are enthusiastic about pizza and have been striving to create the same (and even better) flavor that has been at Long Branch Pizza since 1977. With some favorites such as a Chicago classic pie, a potato pizza, supreme, taco, veggie, and even a stromboli pizza, you have endless options of deliciousness to try out today. Since these women bought Long Branch Pizza, they have helped make the pizza even more memorable, so make sure to check it out for yourself!

“The Old World Style is exactly what we were looking for and we loved it. Delicious and my son said it's his favorite pizza. Italian sub was great too. So glad to have gotten the response about this and now found our new pizza place.” - Yelp Review 

Donatos Pizza

Come to the pizza joint where each slice is as important as the last one!

donatos pizza
Enjoy Donatos Pizza where you can never have enough pepperoni on your slice of pizza, and it’s delicious too! Image courtesy of Delaware County CVB.

101 W Cherry Street | Sunbury |

View homes for sale in 43074>

Want to go somewhere where the pepperoni pizza is literally pepperoni pizza? Who says you can’t have pepperoni cover your entire pizza? If this sounds like it’s right up your alley, then you need to come check out Donatos Pizza today! Donatos Pizza offers their signature pepperoni pizza, along with traditional sauce or dry rubbed chicken wings, their Big Don Italian sub, and even an option to create your very own pizza! Everything is made fresh every single day, so that’s a reason to stop right? We believe that fresh, and delicious pizza quality is a great reason to give this pizza place a try, so make your way over to Donatos Pizza today!

“I'm always a fan of Donatos pizza but it tastes even better at this location! So glad Donatos came to our small town!” - Yelp Review 

Jet’s Pizza

Specializing in deep dish pizza, this is a place you have to come try out when you get the chance!

jet's pizza
Enjoy a slice of deep dish pizza when you come stop by Jet’s Pizza for what tastes like heaven! Image courtesy of Slice Life. 

167 State Route 3 | Sunbury | 

View homes for sale in 43074>

There’s nothing better than some deep dish pizza because of the fluffiness and the flavor it all holds. If you’re thinking about enjoying a slice of this delicious pizza and the other options that are readily available, then you need to try out Jet’s Pizza today! Jet’s Pizza is known for its Detroit-style pizza and it’s crispy and crunchy crust that is known to be a favorite among the people of Sunbury. Also offering favorites such as thin pizza, seasoned cauliflower pizza, New York-style pizza, and even a gluten-free pizza option, this is the place to go to. With all of this being said, we believe that you need to check out Jet’s Pizza today!

“We ordered delivery of a 8 corners all meat with red onions and black olives, AWESOME! Delivery person was very nice. We love this JETS! Bye the way we are from out of state and do not have JETS in Missouri, but would welcome them to our state!!!” - Yelp Review

PJ’s Family Restaurant

Support a local family-owned restaurant and try out their delicious pizza options that you’re going to love!

pj's family restaurant
Enjoy going to a family-owned restaurant such as PJ’s Family Restaurant and enjoy some tasty pizza and other options too! Image courtesy of Delaware Gazette. 

571 W Cherry Street | Sunbury |

View homes for sale in 43074>

Do you wish to support local restaurants around the area of Sunbury, Ohio? If so, then you need to check out PJ’s Family Restaurant today and try out their tasty pizza options, and so much more! PJ’s offers breakfast, lunch, and dinner, so there are endless options to indulge in and everything is made fresh to order. They offer a supreme pizza, meat lover’s, buffalo chicken, taco, and even a BLT pizza that is spectacular. Make sure to stop by PJ’s Family Restaurant today and try out some of the tasty pizza options they have, along with supporting local!

“Today was the third time we have been here and 1st with our kids. We always enjoy the food and place. It's a small town place. Well today really set the bar. They have games as you walk in. So after we ordered we let our kids play at the games. The manager even helped our kids and made sure they were having fun.” - Yelp Review 

The Other Guy Pizza

Try out a pizza and craft beer combo whenever you stop by this pizza joint today! 

The Other Guy Pizza
Try out The Other Guy Pizza that offers many different kinds of mouth watering pizza to satisfy your craving today! Image courtesy of USA Restaurants.

15910 E State Route 37 | Sunbury |

View homes for sale in 43074>

If you want to dive into some of the best pizza around Sunbury, Ohio, another place that you need to stop at when you get the chance is The Other Guy Pizza! The Other Guy Pizza is known for all of their different pizza flavors that you can enjoy, along with some of the tastiest subs around the area. They offer different kinds of pizza, such as pepperoni, cheese, veggie, deluxe, and even meatball pizza. They even have fried bologna sandwiches, veggie sandwiches, and of course, Italian subs. There’s nothing like some fresh pizza and subs, so make sure to try out The Other Guy Pizza today!

“I have heard good things about this place so we decided to give it a try and it did not disappoint.  We ordered a large pizza and garlic bread with cheese and I told him this was our first time there and he threw in garlic knots.  Everything was amazing!” - Yelp Review 

Rise Pies

Made from scratch everyday, try out this restaurant and all the different pizza options they have to offer! 

Rise Pies
Enjoy Rise Pies and their fresh pizza dough that is made fresh daily and all the different topping options you can choose from! Image courtesy of USA Restaurants. 

400 South Wilson Road | Sunbury |

View homes for sale in 43074>

Ready for some delicious pizza from a place that cares about the overall quality of their dough? Well, look no further than Rise Pies in Sunbury today! Located in the Tanger Outlets, Rise Pies is a great place to go to after shopping all day with friends or family. They offer lots of different specialty pizzas, such as chicken bianca, chicken bacon cheddar, chicken caprese, my big fat greek pizza, pepperoni lovers, and even a supreme pizza. All of this sounds outstanding and we know your mouth is watering just thinking about it. If this is the case, (which we know it is) make sure to try out Rise Pies today!

“Delicious pies!! I'm a fan of their crust. It's just enough. Not too thick and not too thin. I'm a pizza purest at heart partial to pepperoni or even just plain cheese pizza.” - Yelp Review 

Cheshire Market

Inside of a convenience store lies this gem that offers traditional pizza options and other Italian favorites!

cheshire market
Stop by Cheshire Market and try out some delicious local pizza in Sunbury, Ohio today! Image courtesy of USA Restaurants. 

5094 Cheshire Road | Galena |

View homes for sale in 43021>

If you are up for travelling just outside of Sunbury, Ohio, we think that it is definitely in your best interest to try out Cheshire Market, a small pizza joint located inside of a convenience store! Cheshire Market is one of the best places to get pizza in all of Ohio and they offer other delicious Italian favorites as well. From stromboli, pizza where you get to customize the toppings, BBQ chicken pizza, buffalo chicken pizza, spaghetti, and even some delicious Italian subs, you’ll be in for a surprise at how delicious this place can really be. Try out Cheshire Market today!

“The pizza was old school square cut, we got pepperoni and they crisped up perfectly. They have these deep fried cheese sticks that are more like cheese filled breadsticks that were AMAZING. We also split an Italian sub, it had lots of meat on it and also was perfectly made. Another fun fact is that their beer on tap is ice cold.” - Yelp Review 

Sunbury, Ohio is a great place to go to. Even though it’s a small town, it is known for all of its delicious and local restaurants that are perfect for any occasion. If you’re looking for the best pizza joint to go to whether you’re visiting the area, or moving or potentially moving there, then we hope we helped you familiarize yourself with the area by providing you with the top eight best pizza places to go in Sunbury!

Is there a pizza joint in Sunbury, Ohio that you love, but we didn’t mention? Let us know in the comments below!

Discover your dream home in German Village, OH.

Learn More
February 10, 2021
For questions on this blog, click here.


All Related content

Be The First to Know. Join Our Newsletter.

Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form