You probably haven’t heard, but the Brookville area of Ohio has some pretty delightful frozen dairy destinations. From homemade custard to froyo, you’re bound to discover a new favorite. There’s even some gluten and dairy free options so even the sensitive stomachs out there can experience the arctic glory of ice cream.

If you live in Brookville and haven’t visited all of these shops, time to change that! If you know you’re going to be visiting Brookville, be sure you don’t leave town until you’ve tried at least one of these spots.

‍

We’ve included locations and yelp ratings for each spot, but in the end it’s up to you to decide which place reigns supreme. Try them all and comment below which is your favorite!

Without further ado, let the ice cream wars commence!

JD’s Old Fashioned Frozen Custard

With a catchphrase like “Taste the difference” you’re going to have high standards when it’s time to taste your order. JD’s won’t let you down! Their old fashioned custard is a favorite among many and even won the Best Ice Cream Parlor in Dayton award for 3 years.

With 30 flavors offered per month you could easily come back and try a new one every day. Flavors include Peanut Butter Brownie, Elephant Stomp, and Blue Moon Cookie Dough. JD’s also sells 3 types of dairy-free italian ice, and 3 gluten-free options.

Location

322 Union RdEnglewood, OH 45322

Yelp Rating

4.5 out of 5 stars

Bratt Tasties

Bratt Tasties is a gem that has the power to delight both the young and old. It’s an old fashioned shop that sells hard candies, high end chocolates, and of course a huge selection of ice cream (32 flavors to be exact)! The aesthetic is amazing, the goodies are unforgettable, and the staff goes above and beyond to make your experience there super sweet!

Location

14 E. Dayton Rd.West Alexandria, OH 45381

Yelp Rating

5 out of 5 stars

Dixie Dairy Dreem

This cutesy, retro ice cream shop is known for their velvety ice cream and thick shakes. They offer malts, sundaes, arctic swirls, and fat-free frozen yogurt. You can also go here to fill your belly with more than just sugar, though. Their food menu sells a variety of hot dogs, burgers, sandwiches, and finger foods like chicken fingers.

They’ve been proudly serving their community for 50 years, so join the tradition and allow them to make your dreems come true!

Location

4542 S Dixie DrMoraine, OH 45439

Yelp Rating

4 out of 5 stars

Rudy’s Dairy Bar

For inexpensive yet quality food, visit Rudy’s Dairy Bar. This family owned ice cream stand gives awesome service and sells different types of hot dogs and tons of ice cream selections. Doesn’t a raspberry dole whip or turtle sundae sound delicious right now? I’m getting hungry!

Location

28572 Oregon RdPerrysburg, OH 43551

Yelp Rating

3.5 out of 5 stars

Brookville Grille

Okay, technically this is an American diner and doesn’t focus specifically on ice cream, but what it does do with ice cream is fantastic. Their scoops are homemade of course, and pair perfectly with a juicy burger and fries, or slice of (also homemade) pie. Some flavor options include bourbon, rum butter pecan, and chocolate hazelnut. Feel more like a milkshake? They do that, too!

Location

428 N Wolf Creek StSte 2Brookville, OH 45309

Yelp Rating

3.5 out of 5 stars

‍