Follow HER Realtors on Instagram!
Around Ohio

10 Amazing Pizza Spots You Have To Try In New Albany, Ohio

All of The Best Pizza Joints in New Albany and the Surrounding Areas


Elizabeth Crawford


Dec 23, 2019

What’s a Rich Text element?



The rich text element allows you to create and format headings, paragraphs, blockquotes, images, and video all in one place instead of having to add and format them individually. Just double-click and easily create content.

Static and dynamic content editing

A rich text element can be used with static or dynamic content. For static content, just drop it into any page and begin editing. For dynamic content, add a rich text field to any collection and then connect a rich text element to that field in the settings panel. Voila!

How to customize formatting for each rich text

Headings, paragraphs, blockquotes, figures, images, and figure captions can all be styled after a class is added to the rich text element using the "When inside of" nested selector system.

For a lot of people finding the perfect slice of pizza in an area is a necessity. So whether you have just moved to the area, are looking to buy a home, or are just a local trying to find what the best spot really is, New Albany, Ohio has some seriously great options for a great pie.

It can be overwhelming trying to choose which place to try first, so to help out we have compiled this list of all the tops spots in the area. No matter what your tastes are, this list has something for you. New Albany is home to New York-style, deep dish Chicago-style, and some local recipes of course. Restaurants range from famous local take- out only to full bar and restaurant with all the fixings. 

Donatos is a family-owned pizza company with more than 150 locations in nine states. Photo courtesy of


Address: 5525 New Albany Road East New Albany OH 43054

Sun - Thurs, 11 am - 12 am
Fri - Sat, 11 am - 1:30 am


Phone Number: (614) 855-7060

Dining Options: Eat-In, Pick Up, Drive-Thru, Delivery, Online Ordering, Catering available

Customer Review:
“One of the reasons why I give Donatos high props is that they pile on the toppings. I really don't know of any place that comes close to Donatos and the shear bulk of products they seem to love adding. They don't lie about "edge to edge". Their quality has always been constantly top notch. If you are specialty pizza nut, this is your place.” 
-  Brian S., Yelp

This store provides handcrafted pizza and entertaining experience in a unique, artistic environment. Photo courtesy of

Mellow Mushroom

Address: 260 Market St, Ste A, New Albany, OH 43054

Mon - Thurs, 11 am - 10 pm
Fri - Sat, 11 am - 11 pm
Sun, 11:30 am - 9 pm
*Happy Hour Mon - Fri, 4 pm - 7 pm


Phone Number: (614) 245-4234

Dining Options: Dine In or Take Out, Online ordering

Customer Review:
“We eat here often and are never disappointed. The salads are fresh, large and never disappoint. We really like the vinaigrette dressing. The pizza crust is delicious and our grandchildren love the garlic cheese bread appetizer. The restaurant is always very clean and employees friendly.”
- Judy R., Yelp

This joint was voted #1 Best Tasting Pizza at the Pepsi Pizza Slice Challenge. Photo courtesy of

Zeros Pizza

Address: 5535 New Albany Rd W New Albany, OH 43054

Mon - Thurs, 10:30 am - 9:30 pm
Fri - Sat, 10:30 am - 10:30 pm
Sun, 12 pm - 9:30 pm


Phone Number: (614) 933-0399

Dining Options: Dine In or Take Out, Online ordering

Customer Review:
“Zeros pizza is always amazing. The ingredients are fresh and plentiful. The healthy choice with whole wheat crust and chicken is my favorite. The crust is thin and crisp. The black magic is a favorite of the meat lovers in my family. Their salads are also fresh with lots of toppings. Staff is friendly and your order is ready in the timeframe expected. I have been a customer since they have opened.. never disappointed.”
- Dona S., Yelp

This restaurant offers a great variety of pizza, subs, sandwiches, dinners, salads, and desserts in a friendly atmosphere. Photo courtesy of

Eagles Pizza

Address: 2 N High St, New Albany, OH 43054

Mon - Thurs, 10:30 am - 10 pm
Fri - Sat, 10:30 am - 11 pm
Sun, 4 pm - 10 pm


Phone Number: (614) 855-2231

Dining Options: Dine in or Carry Out, Catering Available

Customer Review:
“Hometown favorite.  I can't get over the generous amount of toppings and perfectly cooked thin crispy crust. Taco pizza is amazing!!  Subs and sides are all good!  Locally owned since before I was born and friendly staff/owner.”
- Jason F., Yelp

This restaurant prides themselves in the tradition of “providing the perfect pizza” with a one-of-a-kind homemade sauces and dough.  Photo courtesy of

Fracasso’s Pizza

Address: 3699 S. State Rt. 605 Galena, OH


Summer Hours
Mon - Tues, 11 am – 9 pm
Weds - Sat, 11 am – 10 pm
Sun, 4 pm - 9 pm

Winter Hours
Mon - Thurs, 11 am - 9 pm
Fri - Sat, 11 am - 10 pm
Sun, 12 pm - 9 pm 



Phone Number: (740) 965-4711

Dining Options: Dine In or Take Out

Customer Review
“I've been going to Fracassos for 20 years with my family, and just for pick up on the way home from work or wherever. Pizza is amazing, jalapenosjalopenos are hot, house salad dressing is amazing, spaghetti sauce which is Mr. Fracassos original recipe still is amazing, garlic bread is amazing, subs are amazing.” 
- Colleen L., Yelp

You can enjoy our wide variety of appetizers, sandwiches, wings, pizza, and subs while listening to great live music. Photo courtesy of

Flanagan’s Pub

Address: 3001 Reynoldsburg – New Albany Road New Albany, OH 43054

Mon - Sat, 8 am - 1 am
Sun, 12 pm - 9 pm


Phone Number: (614) 855 - 7472

Dining Options:  Dine In or Take Out

Customer Review:
“I love this restaurant/bar the food comes out hot. The beer is cold. The music is great and the service is always on point. I have been going to this place for more then 9 years and I'd say it definitely a place you could bring your family for a great meal, TV's and phenomenalfenominal service. There specialties include pizza, burgers and sandwiches.”
- Shane M., Yelp

This place is known for its incredibly cheesy, veggelicious and buttery square Detroit-style pizza with an out-of-this-world Flavorized crust. Photo courtesy of

Jet’s Pizza

Address: 7356 Fodor Rd, New Albany, OH 43054

Mon - Thurs, 10 am - 10 pm
Fri - Sat, 10 am - 11 pm
Sun, 10 am - 10 pm


Phone Number: (614) 855-2404

Dining Options: Takeout and Delivery, Mobile and Online ordering, Catering available

Customer Review:
“Great experience as always! They'll make your pizza in 15 minutes and everything tastes great! I've had good Jet's, great Jet's, and Jet's that just eh. This is great Jet's! Pro tip: If you can't find the place, it's along the side of the Kroger building.”
- Steve P., Yelp

This popular pizza place was voted #1 Pizza Place in Central Ohio by nine different publications. Photo courtesy of

Masseys Pizza

Address:  261 Lincoln Cir, Columbus, OH 43230

Sun - Thurs, 11 am - 11 pm
Fri - Sat, 11 am - 12 am


Phone Number: (614) 416-4444

Dining Options:  Dine In or Take Out, Delivery and Catering Available

Customer Review:
“This is the best pizza I have ever had, ever! In my 51 years of life, I have traveled a lot and lived in different places but Massey's is my all-time favorite pizza, and in my mind, perfect! Not only is the food great but the customer service when you dine-in is excellent!  The restaurant is clean and efficient and the staff is always friendly and knowledgeable. The whole experience always makes me want to come back and recommend to anyone and everyone. Great job guys!” - Paul F., Yelp

This Italian restaurant is known for its high-quality New York Style Pizza and Homemade Italian Specialties made with only the freshest and finest ingredients. Photo courtesy of

Borgata Pizza Cafe

Address: 5701 Parkville St Columbus, Ohio 43229

Mon - Thurs, 11:30 am - 11 pm
Fri - Sat, 11:30 am - 11:30 pm
CLOSED on Sundays
CLOSED Holidays


Phone Number: (614) 891-2345

Dining Options: Dine In or Take Out, Delivery available through Postmates or Amazon Restaurants

Customer Review:
“ Being in the military...traveling the globe..the United States..I have only one thing to say....BORGATA IS THE BEST ITALIAN CUISINE I'VE EVER HAD! Pizza straight out of The New York Template...pastas from Chicago South-side and that Italian Pizza Rolls to die for!! Long live Borgata!!!
- Reese C., Yelp

This local favorite is home to Frankie’s special recipe pizzas using high-quality ingredients. Photo courtesy of

Frankie’s Pizza

Address: 200 Granville St, Columbus, OH 43230

Tues - Thurs, 4 pm - 9 pm
Fri, 4 pm - 10 pm
Sat, 12 pm - 10 pm
Sun, 4 pm - 9 pm
CLOSED Mondays


Phone Number: (614) 476-5555

Dining Options: Take out only

Customer Review:
“Found out about Frankie's right before I moved from Gahanna. It is by far the best pizza in the area.  I walked in to pick up my order (I don't trust delivery from anywhere) and was greeted by the owner who just got done smoking wings and gave me a whole bag for free since it was my first time there.  Super nice people and really great pizza check it out!”
- Rob S., Yelp

Those are our top 10 picks for pizza in New Albany. Did your favorite make the list? Let us know in the comments!

No items found.
December 13, 2019
For questions, partnerships, or to be featured on this blog, click here.


Be The First to Know. Join Our Newsletter.

Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form